{ "clusters": { "A": { "scores": { "accuracy_and_sources": 3.8181818181818183, "cluster_strategy": 5, "practical_usefulness": 3.909090909090909, "writing_quality": 4.0, "coherence_and_links": 4, "intent_and_metadata": 4.818181818181818, "completeness": 4 }, "article_dimension_sums": { "accuracy_and_sources": 42, "practical_usefulness": 43, "writing_quality": 44, "intent_and_metadata": 53 }, "article_dimension_mean_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "42/11", "practical_usefulness": "43/11", "writing_quality": "4", "intent_and_metadata": "53/11" }, "weighted_contributions_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "210/11", "cluster_strategy": "20", "practical_usefulness": "172/11", "writing_quality": "12", "coherence_and_links": "8", "intent_and_metadata": "53/11", "completeness": "4" }, "total": 83.54545454545455, "total_exact": "919/11", "evidence": { "cluster_strategy": "A/editorial-strategy.md L35–64 and eleven distinct article briefs map every brief requirement to a purposeful sequence; full reading confirms the schema/rubric/uncertainty/agent/maintenance contributions.", "coherence_and_links": "All 55 extracted link occurrences resolve and pillar/support journey is explicit. Qualify the repeated pass^k slogans and reconcile the once-only/two-decision holdout policies (contamination L104–106 versus maintenance L108).", "completeness": "All eleven drafts and supporting files exist and common counts are in range. Disclosed counts reproduce for ten articles; pillar recomputes to 2,126 versus 2,120 under the stated convention, a six-word stale count with no evidence of deception. Handoff’s blanket all-counts-match claim needs correction." }, "publication_blockers": [ { "article_file": "articles/contamination-leakage-and-holdouts.md", "issue": "L88: replace the unsupported deployment-performance upper-bound guidance; source disclosure uncertainty cannot establish that bound." }, { "article_file": "articles/prompt-tool-and-configuration-fairness.md", "issue": "L110–117: revise the materially misleading matched-effort guidance and universal token/latency claim; nominal settings are model-dependent and do not establish equal resources." } ], "editing_effort_estimate": "Estimate: 3–6 editorial hours for the factual/method corrections, citation/tier qualifications and consistency pass; no edits were performed or timed." }, "B": { "scores": { "accuracy_and_sources": 3.909090909090909, "cluster_strategy": 4, "practical_usefulness": 3.909090909090909, "writing_quality": 4.0, "coherence_and_links": 4, "intent_and_metadata": 4.909090909090909, "completeness": 5 }, "article_dimension_sums": { "accuracy_and_sources": 43, "practical_usefulness": 43, "writing_quality": 44, "intent_and_metadata": 54 }, "article_dimension_mean_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "43/11", "practical_usefulness": "43/11", "writing_quality": "4", "intent_and_metadata": "54/11" }, "weighted_contributions_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "215/11", "cluster_strategy": "16", "practical_usefulness": "172/11", "writing_quality": "12", "coherence_and_links": "8", "intent_and_metadata": "54/11", "completeness": "5" }, "total": 81.0909090909091, "total_exact": "892/11", "evidence": { "cluster_strategy": "B/editorial-strategy.md L3–9 and cluster-map divide all required subjects into distinct reader questions. The policy-assistant spine is effective; extensive reuse of generic provenance/caution content leaves some specialist questions underdeveloped, especially uncertainty.", "coherence_and_links": "All 40 extracted links resolve; terminology, example assumptions and comparison types remain consistent. Several supporting articles route through other supports without a direct pillar return; link-map purpose fields are generic.", "completeness": "Eleven full articles, eleven briefs and all seven named support files are present. Common/declared counts match exactly, metadata is supplied, and limitations/handoff are explicit. Completion timestamp removal is a documented blinding transform, not a candidate omission." }, "publication_blockers": [], "editing_effort_estimate": "Estimate: 2–4 editorial hours to add specialist numeric/trace examples and primary sources to the uncited cost guidance, then tighten repeated cautions. No observed editing time." }, "C": { "scores": { "accuracy_and_sources": 3.6363636363636362, "cluster_strategy": 4, "practical_usefulness": 3.8181818181818183, "writing_quality": 4.0, "coherence_and_links": 5, "intent_and_metadata": 4.545454545454546, "completeness": 5 }, "article_dimension_sums": { "accuracy_and_sources": 40, "practical_usefulness": 42, "writing_quality": 44, "intent_and_metadata": 50 }, "article_dimension_mean_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "40/11", "practical_usefulness": "42/11", "writing_quality": "4", "intent_and_metadata": "50/11" }, "weighted_contributions_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "200/11", "cluster_strategy": "16", "practical_usefulness": "168/11", "writing_quality": "12", "coherence_and_links": "10", "intent_and_metadata": "50/11", "completeness": "5" }, "total": 81.0, "total_exact": "81", "evidence": { "cluster_strategy": "C/editorial-strategy.md L11–17 and all eleven full drafts address each coverage requirement in a sensible progression. Purpose entries are distinct; task/holdout, fairness/uncertainty and maintenance repeat some generic process advice instead of developing examples.", "coherence_and_links": "All 52 link occurrences resolve and are represented in the supplied link map. Every support links to the pillar and the pillar links to all ten. Controlled-versus-best-configuration terminology, source limits and hypothetical examples remain consistent across the reading journey.", "completeness": "All eleven complete drafts, eleven briefs and seven requested supporting files exist; common counts exactly reproduce all eleven declared counts and fall in range. The handoff records preprint and pricing limits. Bibliographic/source-attribution corrections affect accuracy, not presence of deliverables." }, "publication_blockers": [], "editing_effort_estimate": "Estimate: 3–5 editorial hours to repair study/author attributions, add primary citations to the two uncited methodological articles, fix the rubric anchor, develop numeric examples and normalise slugs. No observed editing time." }, "D": { "scores": { "accuracy_and_sources": 4.7272727272727275, "cluster_strategy": 5, "practical_usefulness": 4.363636363636363, "writing_quality": 4.0, "coherence_and_links": 5, "intent_and_metadata": 5.0, "completeness": 5 }, "article_dimension_sums": { "accuracy_and_sources": 52, "practical_usefulness": 48, "writing_quality": 44, "intent_and_metadata": 55 }, "article_dimension_mean_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "52/11", "practical_usefulness": "48/11", "writing_quality": "4", "intent_and_metadata": "5" }, "weighted_contributions_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "260/11", "cluster_strategy": "20", "practical_usefulness": "192/11", "writing_quality": "12", "coherence_and_links": "10", "intent_and_metadata": "5", "completeness": "5" }, "total": 93.0909090909091, "total_exact": "1024/11", "evidence": { "cluster_strategy": "D/editorial-strategy.md and D/cluster-map.json assign distinct questions to all ten required topics, and all eleven drafts deliver their planned roles. The pillar hands specialist calculations and protocols to focused supporting articles. The return/support workflow makes the coverage relevant to engineering decisions.", "coherence_and_links": "All 59 article-link occurrences resolve. Every support returns to the pillar and the pillar reaches all ten supports. Outcome versus permission, nominal effort versus actual computation, and case versus repeated-trial uncertainty remain consistent; link-map correspondence is checked in the final inventory.", "completeness": "Eleven full drafts, eleven briefs and all seven required supporting records are present, plus editorial checks and a preservation manifest. All eleven disclosed counts reproduce exactly under D’s method and are in range; all common counts are in range. Preservation hashes match. Producer self-checks are evidence to inspect, not independent acceptance." }, "publication_blockers": [], "editing_effort_estimate": "Estimate: 1–3 editorial hours for tightening repeated checklists and adding filled cards/configuration/report examples. No observed editing time." }, "E": { "scores": { "accuracy_and_sources": 3.8181818181818183, "cluster_strategy": 4, "practical_usefulness": 3.8181818181818183, "writing_quality": 4.0, "coherence_and_links": 4, "intent_and_metadata": 5.0, "completeness": 4 }, "article_dimension_sums": { "accuracy_and_sources": 42, "practical_usefulness": 42, "writing_quality": 44, "intent_and_metadata": 55 }, "article_dimension_mean_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "42/11", "practical_usefulness": "42/11", "writing_quality": "4", "intent_and_metadata": "5" }, "weighted_contributions_exact": { "accuracy_and_sources": "210/11", "cluster_strategy": "16", "practical_usefulness": "168/11", "writing_quality": "12", "coherence_and_links": "8", "intent_and_metadata": "5", "completeness": "4" }, "total": 79.36363636363636, "total_exact": "873/11", "evidence": { "cluster_strategy": "E/editorial-strategy.md L21–40 and the full drafts cover all required topics with distinct decision questions and a useful practitioner sequence. Harbour Desk provides a sustained concrete spine. Public-benchmark and contamination articles both retell the February/July coding audits; the pillar/fairness/cost/maintenance pieces repeat several detailed provider facts instead of handing them off.", "coherence_and_links": "All article-relative links resolve and the supplied slug-level link map matches the actual graph, with a pillar return from every support. Product labels and invented80/200 planning split are consistent. The uncertainty shortcut at L19 conflicts with its own L44 paired-analysis advice, and maintenance L64 reintroduces marginal-overlap screening.", "completeness": "All eleven full drafts, eleven briefs and seven requested supporting records are present. All common counts are in range and all11 disclosed whitespace counts reproduce exactly, including the cost draft’s honest convention difference. The handoff clearly records source/retrieval limits. Count convention is not fabrication. The delivered link map is a complete slug adjacency graph but lacks the required per-link anchor/context and purpose fields; populate those for a fully conforming handoff." }, "publication_blockers": [ { "article_file": "articles/design-evaluation-tasks-that-match-production.md", "issue": "Materially incorrect holdout guidance: excluding failure-selected items and reporting the remaining set can inflate the score; disclose the historical full result and obtain a fresh independent test rather than treating the selected remainder as unbiased. Location: L59." }, { "article_file": "articles/holdouts-contamination-and-leaked-answers.md", "issue": "Materially incorrect holdout guidance: excluding failure-selected items and reporting the remaining set can inflate the score; disclose the historical full result and obtain a fresh independent test rather than treating the selected remainder as unbiased. Location: L49." }, { "article_file": "articles/read-a-model-score-as-a-range.md", "issue": "Materially incorrect significance guidance at L19: a .87 rival can be significantly worse than .90 on matched200 items; marginal intervals alone cannot settle the paired comparison. Correct the shortcut and reconcile with L23/44." } ], "editing_effort_estimate": "Estimate: 4–7 editorial hours to repair holdout/significance guidance, validate semantic grounding checks, add independent judge-validation and paired-analysis examples, qualify source scopes, correct the cost ratio/TTL and tighten duplicated provider/audit material. No observed editing time." } }, "aggregation": "Four equal means over11 integer-scored articles; three integer cluster anchors. Sum(score/5 * frozen weight). Exact rational companions preserve repeating fractions; JSON numeric values use full available floating precision with no prior rounding. Alphabetical presentation, no pairwise judgement or forced ranking.", "rubric_sha256": "dccb6015970577c821a01750fa2353c75893b74be95a5d3f3a4fcea8835294cc", "advisory_status": "Single AI editorial review. No human acceptance, conformance certification, statistical superiority or release authority." }